Stephen Ellis, Compliance Coal Corp., March 2 2015
Mr. Doug Caul
Associate Deputy Minister
PO Box 9426, Stn Prov Govt
Victoria, BC V9W 9V1
Dear Mr. Caul,
We received some misinformation that is circulating in some communities regarding the Raven Project and believe it is appropriate that we withdraw the project from the screening process at this time. We provide this letter as our notice to withdraw our three volume Addendum resubmission from the Environmental Application office forth with.
CoalWatch Comox Valley, February 2015
Myth 1: Investment in coal mining is an investment in jobs
Reality: Coal mining ranks lower than many other industries for numbers of jobs created.
It creates fewer jobs than, for instance, sustainable forestry, agriculture, infrastructure construction, and solar & wind energy production. “State of the art” coal mining technologies lead to even fewer jobs and are no guarantee of environmental or workplace safety.
Scott Stanfield, Comox Valley Record, February 23 2015
Coal licence applications and existing coal tenures in the Valley comprise about a third of the regional district's total land area, according to research conducted by CoalWatch Comox Valley.
Report, Environmental Law Centre, UVic, February 9 2015
Victoria, BC - Over the last decade the BC government embarked on a major law reform initiative to reduce the “regulatory burden” on industry. They reduced the size of the civil service and its role in resource management governance, which increased our dependence upon professionals employed by industry proponents to meet the public interest in natural resource management and environmental protection. This new report, prepared by Mark Haddock and supported with funding from the Law Foundation of BC, evaluates this regulatory approach, identifies issues and makes recommendations for improvement.
Eric Plummer, Alberni Valley Times, February 19, 2015
A committee assembled to evaluate the Raven coal mine's current application to provincial regulators gave a scathing report on the proposed project to city council on Tuesday.
Katya Slepian, Alberni Valley News, Feb 19, 2015
Compliance Coal’s Raven Underground Coal Mine application presents neither a solid business case nor does it properly portray environmental risks posed to the Alberni Valley, said Jane Armstrong, member of the city’s select committee set up to provide input on the latest Raven Coal environmental review process.
Glenda Luymes, The Province, February 17 2015
Despite insatiable demand, many are concerned B.C.’s once-thriving shellfish industry could be sinking.
Tristin Hopper, National Post, February 13, 2015
Built in the 1890s atop one of the richest coalfields in coastal British Columbia, the ground below the village’s downtown is criss-crossed with hundreds of now-flooded mining tunnels.
John Snyder, All Points West, February 12 2015
News Release, CoalWatch Comox Valley, February 12 2015
Recent research done by the CoalWatch Comox Valley Society has revealed that current coal license applications and existing coal tenures in the Comox Valley equal a staggering 33.6% of the total land area in the Comox Valley Regional District.
Sharon Small, Comox Valley Record, February 11 2015
A staggering 33.6 per cent of the Comox Valley is currently covered by coal licence applications and existing coal tenures. Owners, like Compliance Energy, are poised to profit from Premier Clark’s coal mine and coal port expansion program that is pitched to create jobs and economic enhancement.
Editorial, Times Colonist, February 11 2015
The proposed Raven Coal Mine near Fanny Bay faces an uphill battle. That’s the way it should be. The developers must prove that economic benefits outweigh environmental risks, and the provincial government must put the protection of B.C. and its people ahead of short-term profits.
Eric Plummer, Alberni Valley Times, February 4, 2015
A provincial regulator's assessment of a mine that could bring three truckloads of coal to Port Alberni each hour is underway.
Public input on the Raven Underground Coal Project is expected to begin in March if the application proceeds.
CBC On The Island, February 4 2015
The Compliance Coal Corporation put in a new application for the Raven Coal Mine in the Comox Valley. Mike Ruttan is the mayor of Port Alberni, one of the communities that will be affected by the mine.
On The Island host Gregor Craigie talks with Mayor Ruttan about the impacts that the proposed mine will have on Port Alberni, its roads, harbour, air and residents.
Mayor Ruttan on the purported economic benefits to Port Alberni: "The ship ... would only come in once every two weeks. ... In terms of economic impact on balance it potentially would cost us more ... than we would ever make." 4:30
Early take: "There doesn't seem to be much to recommend the project to city residents." 6:30
Alberni Valley Times, February 4, 2015
Note: In November 2014, Port Alberni residents, Maggie Paquet and Jane Armstrong argued that the Port Alberni council should establish an ad hoc committee to be made up of volunteer experts to advise city council and city manager Ken Watson during the 30-day screening of the application for an environmental assessment of the proposed Raven Underground Coal Project.
Council agreed, and this news item lists the members of that ad hoc committee.
Lindsay Kines, Times Colonist, Feb 4 2015
A Vancouver company is once again seeking government approval for a coal mine near Buckley Bay, much to the dismay of environmental groups and shellfish growers in Baynes Sound.
John Harding, Parksville Qualicum Beach News, Feb 3, 2015
Compliance Energy has re-submitted its application for a coal mine less than 50 kilometres from downtown Qualicum Beach.
Media Release, CoalWatch Comox Valley, February 2, 2015
CoalWatch Comox Valley Society has learned the BC Environmental Assessment Office (EAO) has received the latest Application for Environmental Certificate and Environmental Impact Statement (Application/EIS) from Compliance Coal Corporation for the proposed Raven Underground Coal Mine Project near Fanny Bay, BC.
Wendy Stueck, Globe and Mail, Jan. 09 2015
VANCOUVER — If the proposed Murray River coal project goes ahead, more than half of its employees would be temporary foreign workers in 2018 – potentially the first year of operation – and it would take nearly a decade for all the hourly jobs at the project to be filled by Canadians.
Stacey Gaiga, Alberni Valley Times, March 13, 2015
Port Alberni - This letter was mistakenly published in the March 10 Alberni Valley Times with additional material not written by Stacey Gaiga. The Times regrets the error. Here is the original letter in its entirety. [March 10 version]
Compliance Energy dangled the rail option like a carrot to our community since Raven coal's inception because certain officials in Port Alberni are train aficionados whose sole focus and desire is to revive rail; everything else is irrelevant.